I'm so excited to contribute! :) Here's the craft we FINALLY finished a little while ago. I love them!
All they are is a set of three paper boxes (I got mine at Joanne's). I painted them black and then sanded them just a bit and stained them for that more rustic look. I found some cute chipboard letters at Robert's (already orange) and stained those to match. Add some cute ribbon and fun accessories and there you have it!
I'm considering making a small box for Christmas gifts for neighbors (same idea, much smaller scale).